Restaurants in Middlebury, IN

When it’s time to eat, there are plenty of options ranging from family-style Amish meals at Das Dutchman Essenhaus to locally made cheeses, and plenty of pies.

Heritage Ridge Creamery was founded by an Amish man to help bring his community’s products to market. Now owned by farmers, it produces fresh cheese and dairy products with flavors crafted to tempt your taste buds and have you ordering more.

For homemade pies that will transport you back to visiting your grandmother as a child, check out Country Lane Bakery. Pies, cookies, and cinnamon rolls are always made fresh. And grab some handcrafted noodles while you’re there.