Some Great Places To Get Pie In Elkhart County

Who doesn’t love pie? Whether fruit or cream filled, here are great places for a slice, or just the whole pie. Yum!

Featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives on the Food Network, South Side Soda Shop is a must stop
It all started with the peanut butter pie 50 years ago, now there are over 30 varieties at Das Dutchman Essenhaus
Stop counting calories and fill your bag with not just pie but cinnamon rolls, cookies and bread at Country Lane Bakery
Locals love the Village Inn Restaurant where you can get the daily special along with Amish handmade pie

Elkhart

Baker's Nook 127 Easy Shopping Place Elkhart, IN 46516 (574) 970-7445

This locally owned café serves up homemade goodness handed down through generations past. With so many delicious choices, it’s sometimes hard to settle on just one.
Open Monday - Saturday, call for hours.

Rows of small paper plates with assorted slices of pie from Baker's Nook in Elkhart, Indiana

Goshen

South Side Soda Shop 1122 S Main St Goshen, IN 46526 (574) 534-3790 Featured on "The Food Network" and in "Gourmet" magazine. In-house bakery, daily specials, fresh seafood, chili, homemade soups, sandwiches & pie.
Open Wed - Saturday, call for hours.

Middlebury

Das Dutchman Essenhaus Bakery 240 US 20 Middlebury, IN 46540 (800) 455-9471 Fill your basket with unique made-from-scratch favorites like apple butter or our own delicious noodles. Breads, rolls, cookies and over 30 varieties of pie are available fresh-from-the-oven.

Open Monday through Saturday. Closed Sunday, call for hours.

Country Lane Bakery 59162 CR 43, Middlebury, IN 46540 (574) 825-7918 Made-from-scratch bread, cinnamon rolls, cookies, pies and other delicious goodies! Also offers locally made noodles, apple butter, peach butter and peanut butter spread.

Open Tuesday - Saturday, call for hours.

Three pies sit on a rack at Country Lane Bakery in Middlebury, Indiana

Rise 'n Roll 1065 N 1150 W Middlebury, IN 46540 (574) 825-4032 Famed for its cinnamon caramel donuts, mouthwatering pastries & crunch candies - cashew, pecan & nutty. Always serving free coffee and fresh samples. Halfway between Shipshewana and Middlebury on US 20.

Open Monday - Saturday, Call for hours.

Plastic shells filled with pies are stacked two- and three-high next to a group of unbaked pie shells at Rise 'n Roll in Middlebury, IN

Village Inn Restaurant 107 S Main St Middlebury, IN 46540 (574) 825-2043 Amish handmade pies, daily specials, pizza and a whole lot of local charm. Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner.

Open Monday - Saturday, call for hours.

A woman in a red plaid shirt and overalls holds a pie in each hand at Village Inn Restaurant in Middlebury, Indiana

Nappanee

Nappanee Bakery and Treat Shoppe at Coppes Commons 401 E Market St Nappanee, IN 46550 (574) 773-0139 Nappanee’s Bakery & Treat Shoppe specializes in making our baked goods the old fashioned way. Specialty items include pies, (shoestring apple, Bob Andy, peanut butter & chocolate), whoopie pies, (chocolate, pumpkin, oatmeal, mocha, red velvet, carrot, & chocolate peanut butter), cinnamon rolls, and wheat bread.

Open Tuesday - Saturday, call for hours.